LIFE
WITH MOTHER
In Europe more women are having children out of wedlock and no
one seems to care
IT'S midnight in
smoky Karaoke bar in Copenhagen. Karina, 24, is belting out old
Diana Ross tunes. A cook in a restaurant by day, Karina aspires
to rock stardom by night. But lately she has another ambition :
motherhood-a kind of Karaoke motherhood, as it were, with the
lead performer going it alone.
"Whether there's a husband or not, I don't care", she
says. Her boyfriend evaporated after she got pregnant three
months ago, and she's regretting the abortion she had when he
left. "Next time the opportunity comes up I'm gonna take
it," she says, determination settling over her freckled
face.
Maybe she should meet Kim, an 18-year-old from Jutland, sitting
across the room. "Marriage is just a fairy tale," he
says. "I just don't believe in it."
Does anyone in Europe believe in marriage any more? In
Scandinavia, the generation that first eschewed the ritual is
already having grand kids. The pages of Paris Match have long
featured the out-of-wedlock off-spring of the Eurostars. But now,
all over Europe, single motherhood is promising to change the
demographic face of the continent.
Some of these single parents are teenagers who no longer feel
that an unplanned pregnancy need be a mistake. A few are women
who simply decide to raise a child alone. Most are mothers who
may live with the father, at least for a while, but just don't
see the point of marrying him.
In Sweden, more than half of all babies are born to unmarried
parents; in France and England, it's about one in three.
Virtually nobody gives up a baby for adoption anymore. In the
modern European wedding, the bride and groom's own children are
often the flower girls and ring bearers.
"The place of marriage in French society has changed
altogether,"says Jean Claude Kaufmann of the National Center
for Scientific Research. "Thirty years ago it was the
beginning of a relationship. Today it's the culmination."
It's a social revolution that is confounding the old categories:
what, exactly, is a family? In Denmark, "single"
parents are so often cohabiting that the state statistical office
has started counting them as married any way. In Ireland, where
divorce will become possible only this year and abortion is still
illegal, unmarried mothers are more common than married ones in
some city neighbourhoods (low-income ones, mostly). All over
Europe, in fact, single mothers are downright unremarkable. Much
more controversial are single fathers, who are demanding to be
treated equally in custody battles (box).
But may be people should be worried. Among some experts, there's
a creeping fear that single motherhood can bring with it a host
of social pathologies: poverty, drugs, low education and low
employment. In the United States, out-of-wedlock births actually
fell four per cent last year, for the first time in nearly 20
years, but in the ghetto four out of five children are still born
to single mothers.
The American debate has echoes now in Britain. "Cohabiting
families are usually among the poorest in Britain.
"Cohabiting families are usually among the poorest in
society," says Kathleen Liernan of the London School of
Economics. "There seems to be a misperception afoot."
Still, the broad acceptance of single motherhood shows that
sexual politics in Europe has changed for good in the last
decade. Nowhere is that more clear than in Ireland, the country
where the traditional balance of power between men and women has
been most resistant to change. The Roman Catholic Church has lost
much of its moral authority, and a vigorous women's movement has
taken a high social profile. "A lot of women are deciding
they don't need men in order to survive," says Noreen Byrne
of the National Women's Council. Mary Robinson, the country's
first woman president, represents a kind of symbolic
encouragement of this independence.
It's hard to pinpoint the exact moment when the last shreds of
stigma finally disappeared. but in France, perhaps it was the
spring of 1996, when President Jacques Chirac publicly celebrated
the birth of his grandson Martin. Chirac's daughter, Claude,
refused at first even to name the father publicly, much less
marry him.
In Britain, may be it was last year, when former rock star Bob
Gledof, divorced with three children, told the tabloids of his
sympathy for the plight of lone dads.
In Scandinavia marriage rates are climbing slightly but are still
so low that cohabiting has become part of the national
self-image. "Living together without being married is part
of being Danish," explains Copenhagen psychologist Bodil
Pedersen.
Tax breaks and welfare policies in many countries actually
discourage people from marrying. Anja, a 20 something Berliner
who recently bore twin boys, is living with the boys' father, a
tax consultant. But if she married him, she'd lose an extra
year's worth of child-care subsidies, at $400 a month.
Married women get benefits for only six months. In Copenhagen,
not only do single mothers get additional cash, but underage
single mothers get more still. The state pays Betina Johansen an
extra $500 a month, plus the rent on her apartment, because she's
under 18. She'd lose almost all those benefits if she married her
boyfriend (who has three kids by previous girlfriends).
What's available for pregnant teenagers in Copenhagen would make
an American social worker weep with envy. Johansen goes to a high
school, where girls take a 24-week course in how to care for
babies. They paint their distended bellies with fanciful patterns
and hang photographs of themselves around the classroom, which is
practically clean enough to eat off the floor.
After the child is born, they get more training in health and
nutrition plus a choice of vocational programmes. They also learn
about Danish welfare law, and what benefits they're entitled to.
Such liberal benefits do provoke jealousy among more traditional
fellow citizens. There's a widespread conviction in Ireland that
women have babies in order to jump the lime for public housing,
for example.
Even the generous Danes envy the speed with which single parents
get space in oversubscribed day-care centres. But when European
societies get serious about cutting budgets, benefits to needy
families are sacrosanct.
The political consensus for supporting single mothers is
remarkably firm. Bu and large, European conservatives have
morally accepted the notion of single motherhood. After years of
falling birthrates, many right-wing politicians who might bemoan
the decline of the family find themselves grateful that people
are still having babies at all.
Says a doctor in a Paris maternity clinic: 'Every French baby is
welcome."
In Germany, a negative birthrate has threatened for years to
bankrupt the pension system, as an ever smaller cadre of young
people is asked to support an ever larger cadre of old ones. For
Germans, any kind of motherhood is politically unassailable.
Yet some politicians are beginning to worry. In Britain, single
motherhood has become a political football. Back in 1992, Social
Security Secretary Peter Lilley claimed he had "a little
list of young ladies" who supposedly had gotten pregnant out
of wedlock in order to collect more benefits from the state.
Last spring Lilley caused another uproar by proposing to dock
benefits to single mothers who refused to give the fathers' names
to the child support agency. Education Secretary Gillian Shephard
now wants to implement a moral code for schools that puts more
emphasis on "the value of the family as a bulwark of
society".
But the conservatives are losing the issue to Labour Party leader
Tony Blair, with his wife the three wholesome kids, who has
explicitly made "family values" part of his public
appeal. He's careful, however, not to stigmatise single parents,
which he accuses the Tories of doing.
Blair has caught hold of a hot topic. With 70 per cent of all
single mothers receiving some kind of public assistance,
something frighteningly like the American underclass is beginning
to develop in Britain's inner cities: stubborn pockets of drugs,
poverty and hopelessness, with teenage moms who drop out of high
school and never get a job. Kiernan of the London School of
Economics says kids from single-parent families are more likely
to leave school early, to become teenage parents themselves and
to be unemployed."
Even in a rich country like Denmark, single parents are twice as
likely as the rest of the population to be poor. Danes recoil
with disdain at the suggestion that single motherhood can cause
social problems; they consider it a highly "American"
idea. Yet Vibeke Backmann, a social worker in Copenhagen, isn't
sure Denmark can remain immune from the plagues of the American
underclass.
"There are no traditional families today, and children from
these broken families are not able to make stable relationships
themselves," Backmann says. "This leads to crime and to
drugs and to violence. Denmark is going to be more similar to the
United States.
The link to unemployment is what already scares European policy
makers. Single parents have a higher unemployment rate than
married people and their unemployment rate has grown faster.
In Denmark in 1974, 11 per cent of single parents were
unemployed: now the number is close to 30 per cent. The links
between single parenthood and joblessness aren't entirely clear,
though. When jobs are scarce, young girls may decide to have a
baby because there isn't much else to do.
"For a middle-class woman who can aspire to travel and work,
there's no reason to get pregnant", says Margot Dohery of
Treoir, a clearing house for single parents in Dublin.
"For a lower-class woman, there's no reason not to get
pregnant."
Europe's stagnant economies, with their high unemployment rates,
are not generating the flexible jobs that many parents, but
especially single parents, prefer.
"Work is very anti-family", says Doherty, voicing the
views of young others. In some cases the state also discourages
part-time employment. In Denmark, single parents lose their free
rent and other social benefits if they find part-time employment.
In Denmark, single parents lose their free rent and other social
benefits if they find part-time work. Says Mogens Christofferson
of Danish national Institute of Social Research: "Single
mothers feel very isolated because they are unemployed".
Even without the overt social stigmas, single mothers complain of
street. "Money is not the only thing women need", says
Backman. 'They need friends, family; they need network."
Maybe that's why marriage rates have started edging up again in
Denmark. "Our generation did away wit all the traditions and
rituals," says Elisabeth Flensted-Jensen, 47, a Copenhagen
single mother. "The next generation doesn't feel very close
to the rituals but they are the only ones available."
But there's something very post-modern Dabish wedding. "What
these young people want is the day, not the marriage, " says
psychologist Ben Maries Sondergaard. "They want the dress
and the carriage and the horses. It's a revival of romantic
performance."
Every revolution has its counter revolution. In the 90s the idea
of family is "in". Research by the Copenhagen institute
for Future Studies shows that young people, even 15 and
16-year-olds, consider family to be the top priority in their
lives and they expect it still to be so in 10 years' time. For
them, says the institute's Maria Therese Hoppe, family "has
nothing to do with economic support. It has to do with whom you
cry to at the end of the day." For all the brave rhetoric
about modern relationships, everyone still needs someone to hold
the box of tissues.
CARROLL BIGERT